---

title: "Best Self-Hosted Budget Planners Compared in 2024: Features, Privacy & Setup" description: "We compare the top self-hosted budget planners — Actual Budget, Firefly III, and BudgetStill — on privacy, features, Docker setup, and what-if scenario support." publishedAt: "2024-01-15" author: "BudgetStill Team" tags: ["self-hosted", "budget planner", "comparison", "privacy", "open source"] featured: true

Best Self-Hosted Budget Planners Compared in 2024: Features, Privacy & Setup

Your bank knows what you spend. Your budgeting app knows what you plan to spend. And if that app lives on someone else's server, your most intimate financial decisions sit in a database you don't control. For a growing number of privacy-conscious people, that's a deal-breaker — and it's exactly why the self-hosted budget planner category is exploding.

Whether you're searching for a self-hosted alternative to YNAB after yet another price hike, or you simply want your financial data to never leave your home network, 2024 offers more capable options than ever. In this post, we'll compare three of the most popular choices — Actual Budget, Firefly III, and BudgetStill — across the dimensions that actually matter: privacy, features, setup complexity, and long-term usability.

Why Self-Host Your Budget Planner?

Before we dive into the comparison, let's address the "why" for anyone still on the fence.

Your Data Stays Yours

Cloud-based tools like YNAB and Mint require you to hand over transaction data, income details, and savings goals to a third party. A self-hosted budget planner keeps everything on hardware you own — a Raspberry Pi, a NAS, or a $5/month VPS. No tracking. No data mining. No surprise policy changes.

No Subscription Lock-In

YNAB now costs $99/year. When the price goes up again (and it will), your only leverage is to leave — and take your data with you. With an open source YNAB alternative, you own the software and the data. Forever.

Offline-First Is Underrated

Internet goes down? Cloud app goes down? With an offline budget planning app, you keep working. Sync when you're ready. No dependency on someone else's uptime.

The Contenders: Actual Budget vs. Firefly III vs. BudgetStill

Here's how the three most popular self-hosted budget planners stack up in 2024.

| Feature | Actual Budget | Firefly III | BudgetStill | |---|---|---|---| | Envelope budgeting | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | | What-if scenarios | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ | | Docker support | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | | Offline mode | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | | Bank sync | ✅ (via SimpleFIN) | ✅ (via Spectre/Nordigen) | Manual / CSV import | | Multi-currency | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | | Learning curve | Low | High | Low | | Active maintenance | Community-driven | Active | Active |

Actual Budget

Actual Budget went open source in 2023 after its original creator stepped away. It's fast, clean, and follows YNAB's envelope method closely. If you want a near-identical self-hosted alternative to YNAB, Actual is a strong pick. The downside? Feature development is community-driven, which means progress can be slow and unpredictable.

Firefly III

Firefly III is the power user's dream. It handles multi-currency accounts, recurring transactions, piggy banks, and detailed reporting. But that power comes at a cost: the learning curve is steep. Setup requires PHP, a database, and patience. It's the most full-featured option, but it's not for someone who just wants to answer "can I afford this?"

BudgetStill

BudgetStill takes a different approach. Instead of drowning you in transaction history, it focuses on forward-looking financial planning. Its standout feature is what-if scenario modeling — "What happens to my savings timeline if I switch jobs?" or "Can I afford this car payment and max out my 401k?" It's the only tool on this list designed specifically to help you plan your future, not just categorize your past.

Setting Up a Self-Hosted Budget Planner with Docker

One of the most common setups for any budget planner docker self-host deployment is Docker Compose. Here's a general example of how lightweight these deployments can be:

version: "3.8"
services:
  budgetstill:
    image: budgetstill/app:latest
    ports:
      - "3000:3000"
    volumes:
      - ./data:/app/data
    environment:
      - NODE_ENV=production
    restart: unless-stopped

That's it. A single container, a mounted volume for persistent data, and you're budgeting in minutes. No external database required. No PHP. No Redis.

Compare that to Firefly III, which typically requires a separate MariaDB or PostgreSQL container, environment variable configuration for mail, and a cron container for recurring transactions. It works, but "simple" it is not.

For most people exploring self-hosting for the first time, the friction of setup directly predicts whether they'll actually use the tool. A one-container deployment removes the single biggest barrier to adoption.

What Makes BudgetStill Different?

Most budget planners answer the question: "Where did my money go?"

BudgetStill answers a more useful one: "Where is my money going — and what can I change?"

Scenario-Based Planning

Create multiple financial scenarios side by side. Model a career change. Test what happens if you aggressively pay down debt versus investing. See the impact of a new expense before you commit to it. No other self-hosted budget planner offers this out of the box.

Built for Real Decisions

BudgetStill isn't trying to replace your bank's transaction feed. It's designed for the moments that actually shape your financial life — the big decisions. Should you rent or buy? Take the higher-paying job with no 401k match, or stay put? These are the questions that a categorized pie chart will never answer.

Privacy Without Compromise

BudgetStill runs entirely in your browser or on your own server. There are no accounts to create on a third-party platform. No telemetry. No analytics. Your financial models exist on your hardware and nowhere else — making it a true offline budget planning app that respects your privacy by default, not by policy.

Choosing the Right Tool for You

Here's the honest breakdown:

• Choose Actual Budget if you want a faithful YNAB clone that runs on your own server and you're comfortable with community-paced development.
• Choose Firefly III if you need granular transaction tracking, multi-currency support, and you don't mind a complex setup.
• Choose BudgetStill if you care more about planning your financial future than cataloging your financial past — and you want to be up and running in under five minutes.

The best open source YNAB alternative depends entirely on what problem you're actually solving. If it's "I need to track every coffee purchase," you have great options. If it's "I need to make a confident financial decision this week," there's really only one.

Start Planning Smarter Today

Your financial future shouldn't live on someone else's server — and it shouldn't be limited to looking backward. BudgetStill gives you private, scenario-driven budget planning that helps you make better decisions, not just better spreadsheets.

👉 Try BudgetStill free at budgetstill-budget-planner.onmindo.com — no sign-up, no tracking, no strings attached.